Liability-Driven Investing for DIY Investors: Hedge Your Spending, Then Take Risk
For one modeled retiree, $800k in an aggregate bond fund hedged 38% of their spending's rate risk. What LDI is, how it differs from ALM, and how to size it.
Take one modeled retiree on December 31, 2021: $2 million invested 60% in global stocks and 40% in bonds, needing $60,000 a year from the portfolio, rising with inflation, for 30 years. Priced on that day’s Treasury real yield curve, that spending cost $2.02 million. A year later, with an aggregate bond fund as the 40%, the portfolio had fallen 16%, and the same spending cost $1.53 million, 24% less, because 30-year real yields had gone from −0.44% to 1.67%. Measured against what it had to pay for, the household ended 2022 better funded than it started, whichever bond fund it owned.
Pension funds have measured themselves this way for decades. They call the investment side of it liability-driven investing (LDI): price the obligations at market rates, hedge the part you cannot afford to miss, and take risk with what is left. This guide translates that for an individual: how to price your own spending, how to tell how much of its interest-rate risk your bonds offset, what that looked like in 2020 to 2022, and where the pension playbook does not fit a household.
ALM, Immunization and LDI
The terms overlap, and guides use them loosely. They answer different questions:
| Term | Question it answers | Typical tool |
|---|---|---|
| Asset-liability management (ALM) | Can the balance sheet meet its obligations, and what threatens that? | Funded ratio, cash-flow projections, scenario tests |
| Cash-flow matching | Which bonds pay exactly what is due, when it is due? | A bond or TIPS ladder |
| Immunization | Which bonds move in value like the obligations when rates change? | Duration and dollar-duration matching |
| Liability-driven investing (LDI) | How much of the portfolio should hedge the obligations, and how much should seek return? | A hedging portfolio plus a growth portfolio |
Immunization is the oldest of the four. Frank Redington, the Prudential’s actuary, set out in a 1952 paper the conditions under which an insurer’s assets and liabilities respond alike to a small change in interest rates. Fisher and Weil (1971) worked out how a bondholder could lock in a return over a set horizon by holding a portfolio whose duration equals that horizon. Our asset-liability matching guide covers the duration math for a household’s spending plan. LDI adds the sizing decision: the hedge is measured in dollars, and a household chooses how much of its liabilities to hedge rather than matching the duration of whatever bonds it happens to hold.
Step One: Price the Spending
A liability’s market value is what it would cost today to buy assets that pay it with certainty. For spending that rises with inflation, those assets are Treasury Inflation-Protected Securities (TIPS), so the discount rates come from the Treasury real yield curve:
where is the spending due in year in today’s dollars and is today’s price of a dollar of real income in year , bootstrapped from the TIPS par curve. That sum is also the cost of a TIPS ladder that funds the spending, which is why Summitward’s ladder planner, health score and duration match now use it. A fixed-dollar obligation, such as a fixed-rate mortgage, is priced on the nominal Treasury curve instead.
Two choices change the answer more than the math does. The first is which spending counts. A pension values a contractual promise; a household has essential spending it would struggle to cut and discretionary spending it could. LDI is about the first kind. The second is what already covers it. Social Security is a CPI-indexed lifetime income, so its payments come off the spending before you price what is left, as our guide to Social Security and asset allocation recommends.
For one modeled retiree, aged 65, with $80,000 of essential spending a year through age 95 and $30,000 of Social Security from 67, the spending cost $1.56 million on the Treasury real curve of October 15, 2026 (10-year 2.78%, 30-year 3.18%). Social Security covered $557,000 of that, leaving $1.01 million for the portfolio to fund. On a $2 million portfolio, that is a funded ratio of 1.99.
Step Two: Measure the Hedge
A liability priced on the yield curve moves when yields move. The quantity that matters is its dollar duration, or DV01: the dollar change in value for a one-basis-point fall in yields. Bonds hedge the liability to the extent their DV01 offsets it:
where and are the market values of the bonds and the liability and and their durations. A ratio of 100% means a parallel move in real yields leaves assets minus liabilities unchanged. Matching durations in years, the usual advice, gets this right only when the bonds are worth as much as the liability they are meant to fund.
For the modeled retiree, the $1.01 million of spending has a duration of 12.6 years. Here is how $800,000 of bonds, 40% of the portfolio, hedges it on the October 15, 2026 curve, using fund durations from Summitward’s March 2026 catalog:
- Aggregate bond fund (BND, duration 6.1): 38%. A full hedge at that duration would take $2.09 million of BND, more than the whole portfolio.
- Broad TIPS fund (SCHP, duration 6.6): 41%.
- TIPS ladder built to the spending (duration 12.6): 79%, because $800,000 is less than the $1.01 million liability.
- Long TIPS fund (LTPZ, duration 20.0): 126%. Too much: a rise in real yields would cost the fund more than it saves on the liability.
- T-bills: 1%.
In this scenario a one-point fall in real yields cuts the BND household’s surplus by about $78,000. The aggregate fund carries a second risk the TIPS options do not: if expected inflation rises a point with real yields unchanged, nominal bonds lose about $49,000 while CPI-linked spending costs the same in real terms. Try your own numbers:
What 2022 Did to a Retiree’s Funded Ratio
Hedging cuts both ways, and recent history shows both directions. We followed the opening example’s retiree month by month: $2 million on the start date, $60,000 a year in start-date dollars withdrawn each December and grown with CPI-U, 60% in Vanguard Total World Stock (VT) and 40% in one of five bond sleeves, rebalanced annually. The liability is repriced every month on Treasury’s real par curve. Four sleeves are funds, with returns from adjusted closing prices; the fifth is a modeled position that earns exactly what the liability’s own cash flows earn, with no costs, which stands for a perfect TIPS ladder. Like every sleeve here it is 40% of the portfolio, so it hedges about 40% of the liability, not all of it.
In calendar 2022, every household started at a funded ratio of 0.99 and the cost of its spending fell 24%. The ending funded ratios ranked in reverse order of how much rate risk each sleeve hedged:
- T-bills: 1.17
- Broad TIPS fund: 1.10
- Aggregate bonds: 1.10
- Matched TIPS (modeled): 1.04
- Long TIPS fund: 1.00
The two years before ran the other way. From the end of 2019 to the end of 2021, 30-year real yields fell from 0.58% to −0.44%, and the payments still due on a 30-year spending stream set at the start of 2020 cost 20% more than the whole stream had two years earlier. Starting from a funded ratio of 1.18, the long TIPS sleeve ended at 1.27 and the modeled matched sleeve at 1.25, while T-bills ended at 1.13 and aggregate bonds at 1.16.
That symmetry is what a hedge is. The unhedged household wins when rates rise and loses when they fall, so being unhedged is itself a position on rates. Over the full stretch from December 2021 to September 2026, the matched sleeve gave the steadiest funded ratio in our model, an annualized volatility of 5.8% against 6.9% for T-bills, while T-bills ended highest because real yields rose from below zero to over 3%. Since December 2011 the matched sleeve was again the steadiest and T-bills the least steady (8.3% and 9.3%). The differences are small because 60% of every portfolio is stocks, which move the funded ratio far more than the choice of bond fund.
Pensions saw the same thing in 2022 at larger scale: corporate plans lost money on their assets and still ended the year better funded, because their liabilities fell faster. Is locking in today’s TIPS yields market timing? has those figures.
Where Household LDI Breaks Down
The liability is softer than a pension’s
A pension owes benefits defined by contract. A retiree’s spending is an estimate that changes with health, housing, family and taste, and much of it can be cut after a bad year. Hedging discretionary spending buys certainty for an amount nobody committed to. The part worth pricing and hedging is the floor: housing, food, insurance, and the other costs that would hurt to cut.
Longevity outlasts a fixed-term ladder
A 30-year ladder is a perfect hedge for 30 years. Longevity risk remains, and only pooling covers it. Yaari (1965) showed that, without a bequest motive, a retiree facing uncertain lifespan does best buying fair annuities. A practical version comes from Sexauer, Peskin and Cassidy (2012): a 20-year TIPS ladder plus a deferred life annuity that begins when the ladder ends, which in their example took 88% and 12% of the money. All prices in this guide assume a fixed end age, so they understate what lifetime spending costs for someone who lives past it.
Personal inflation and taxes
TIPS principal tracks CPI-U, and Social Security’s cost-of-living adjustment uses CPI-W. A household whose health-care or housing costs outrun either index is unhedged on the difference. In a taxable account, the IRS taxes each year’s inflation increase in TIPS principal as income before you receive it, so a ladder that funds a real spending stream before tax funds less after it. Holding the hedge in an IRA or 401(k) avoids the annual tax on the adjustment; our replication of Elm Wealth’s TIPS test works through the after-tax numbers.
The hedge costs expected return
Money in a matched TIPS ladder earns the real yield and no equity premium. A household that hedges more than its floor gives up expected wealth it might have spent or left to heirs. The trade is worth making when a shortfall in essentials would be costly and hard to undo, which is a judgment about the household, not about markets. Bodie (1995) showed why a long horizon does not remove the need: the cost of insuring a stock portfolio against falling short of the risk-free return rises with the horizon.
Borrowing turned a hedge into a crisis in the UK
British defined-benefit pensions ran LDI with borrowed exposure: gilt repurchase agreements and swaps that let a fund hedge more liability than its bond holdings alone could cover. When 30-year gilt yields rose about 1.3 percentage points in three trading days in late September 2022, according to the Bank of England’s own account, those positions demanded collateral the funds raised by selling gilts, which pushed yields higher still. On September 28 the Bank announced it would buy long gilts “on whatever scale is necessary” and ended up buying £19.3 billion. The higher yields had reduced what the pensions owed; the problem was cash to meet margin calls in the meantime. An individual holding TIPS outright, without borrowing, faces no margin call. The lesson for a household is to hedge with assets it owns outright.
What We Recommend
- Price your essential spending at market rates. List the costs you could not cut, subtract Social Security and any pension, and value the rest on the Treasury real curve. The health dashboard does this with your saved liabilities.
- Hedge the spending floor. If you are retired or within a few years of it and comfortably funded at market prices, a TIPS ladder sized to the essential spending, held in a tax-deferred account, is the closest thing to a riskless position a household can own. Keep discretionary spending in a diversified growth portfolio and let it flex.
- If you are underfunded, do not spend the growth assets on a partial floor. In our income-floor simulations for one modeled 65-year-old, buying a partial floor lowered the chance of meeting spending below roughly 0.65 times funded. The better levers there are spending, work and claiming age.
- For a bond sleeve against real spending, prefer TIPS sized by dollar duration. An aggregate bond fund hedges real spending only partly and adds inflation risk. Use the calculator to check the hedge ratio before choosing a fund.
- Before retirement, your earnings are most of the hedge. A 40-year-old’s future paychecks fund most of their future spending; see lifecycle asset allocation and the Merton share for how that shifts the stock-bond split.
- Never borrow to hedge.
What the Evidence Shows, and What Is Theory
The case for LDI rests mostly on theory and on how bonds are built, not on backtests showing higher returns. Three pieces are well established:
- A matched bond hedges a matched liability. This is arithmetic: a TIPS paying a CPI-adjusted dollar in 2040 has the same value today as a CPI-adjusted dollar of spending due in 2040.
- For long-horizon spending, cash is not the safe asset. Campbell and Viceira (2001) showed that an infinitely risk-averse investor with a long horizon should hold long inflation-indexed bonds, which finance a riskless consumption stream; in their 2009 paper with Shiller, they put it as “Treasury bills are not safe assets for long-term investors.”
- Real yields move a lot. In our model, the payments left on a 30-year spending stream set at the end of 2019 cost 20% more two years later; one set at the end of 2021 cost 24% less a year later.
Weaker or missing: there is no controlled evidence that households following an LDI policy end up better off, and our backtest is one path for one modeled household. Nominal bonds have not been a stable hedge either; Campbell, Sunderam and Viceira (2017) document how their correlation with stocks has changed sign over time. And the TIPS yield used to price the liability includes a liquidity premium that varies, so the “market cost” of spending is itself an estimate.
Key Takeaways
- LDI prices spending at market rates and sizes a hedge against it. ALM is the broader balance-sheet check; cash-flow matching and duration matching are ways to hedge.
- The hedge ratio is dollar duration divided by dollar duration. For one modeled retiree with $1.01 million of net spending, $800,000 in an aggregate bond fund offset 38% of its rate risk and the same dollars in a long TIPS fund offset 126%.
- Hedging is symmetric. In our model, the least-hedged household gained most in 2022 and lost most in 2020 and 2021; over the longer windows the matched sleeve gave the steadiest funded ratio.
- Hedge essentials with assets you own outright. Longevity, personal inflation and taxes stay unhedged by a ladder, and borrowing is what broke UK pension LDI in 2022.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is liability-driven investing in simple terms?
Working out what your future obligations cost today, holding assets that rise and fall with that cost for the part you must pay, and investing the rest for growth. Pension funds use it; a household can use the same idea for essential spending in retirement.
What is the difference between LDI and asset-liability matching?
Asset-liability matching usually means lining up the timing of bonds with the timing of spending, by cash flows or by duration. LDI adds the sizing: how much of the obligation to hedge, measured in dollars of interest-rate sensitivity, and what to do with the money that is not hedging.
Is a bond fund with the same duration as my spending a hedge?
Only if the fund is worth about as much as the spending it is meant to cover. A fund worth half the liability offsets about half its interest-rate risk at equal duration. A nominal fund also leaves you exposed to rising inflation expectations, which do not raise TIPS-like spending costs in real terms but do lower nominal bond prices.
Should I count Social Security as a bond?
For pricing your liabilities, subtract it from the spending it covers, which is how Summitward’s dashboard treats it. That is cleaner than adding an estimated “bond value” to your portfolio, because Social Security cannot be sold and its value depends on how long you live.
Did LDI fail in the UK in 2022?
The hedges worked as hedges: higher gilt yields lowered what the pensions owed. What failed was the borrowing. Funds that had borrowed to hedge faced collateral calls they could only meet by selling gilts into a falling market, until the Bank of England stepped in.
Related Guides
- What Makes an Investment Safe? for which asset matches which bill, scored on data since 1928.
- Asset-Liability Matching for duration buckets and a worked example with four liabilities.
- How to Build a TIPS Ladder for the mechanics of a matched hedge, the 2037 to 2039 gap, and a pricing calculator.
- How Much of Your Retirement Should Be a Guaranteed Income Floor? for when a floor helps and when it hurts.
- Are TIPS Safer Than They Seem? for spending-power risk across TIPS, Treasuries and bills since 2000.
- Understanding Your CEFR Score for the funded ratio after taxes and liquidity.
- What’s in Your 40? for what different bond sleeves did when stocks fell.
More in Retirement Planning
Browse all retirement planning guidesGet new guides by email
Evidence-based, no jargon. At most two emails a month. Unsubscribe any time.
Try it in Summitward
See financial health analysis in action with your own financial data. Free to start, no credit card required.