Should I Buy More Stocks? Four Investors, One Portfolio, Four Answers
62% of investors under 35 say they need big risks to reach their goals. Four 28-year-olds with the same $40,000 show why the answer depends on the goal.
I posted this from my Engineer Investor account on November 18, 2026:
“One of the most common mistakes I see young investors make is asking for investment advice without articulating their financial goals or having a plan.
Without knowing what you’re working toward, how can anyone tell you whether your asset allocation is appropriate or whether you should buy more stocks?
Start with goals, then work backward to build a financial plan and portfolio that provide favorable odds of achieving them.”
Disclosure: I write both Summitward and the Engineer Investor account.
Below, four 28-year-olds hold the same $40,000 in a stock index fund, save the same $1,000 a month, and ask the same question. Each has a different goal. Run each goal through US market data back to 1928 and the verdicts split: stocks had the deepest losses for one person’s money and the best record for another’s.
The short version
- Buy more stocks with money you will not need for many years, once high-interest debt is gone and a cash reserve is in place.
- Money with a near date belongs in T-bills, a CD or a Treasury that matures before you need it.
- If your plan works only at a return stocks rarely delivered, save more, wait longer or shrink the goal. A riskier bet does not reliably close the gap.
- If you cannot name the goal yet, a target-date or global index fund plus a cash reserve is a sound default until you can.
Why the question needs a goal
Young investors are more likely to believe the answer is more risk. In the FINRA Foundation’s 2024 survey of investors, 62% of those under 35 agreed that “I need to take big risks with my investments in order to reach my financial goals,” against 16% of those 55 and older.1 In the Federal Reserve’s household survey for 2025, 22% of non-retirees aged 18 to 29 thought their retirement saving was on track.2
Neither survey says young people plan less. In Schwab’s 2025 survey, 39% of Gen Z respondents said they had documented their goals in a formal plan, more than the 26% of baby boomers who said so.3 The mistake in my post is about how the question gets asked, which none of these surveys measures.
People who answer these questions regularly ask about your situation first. Since 2007 the Bogleheads forum has asked newcomers to fill in a template before asking for portfolio help, because its regulars “can’t or won’t give advice in a vacuum.”4 A broker recommending an investment to a retail customer needs a reasonable basis, grounded in that customer’s investment profile, to believe it is in the customer’s best interest. The SEC’s Regulation Best Interest and FINRA’s suitability rule list the same nine items in that profile: age, other investments, financial situation and needs, tax status, investment objectives, experience, time horizon, liquidity needs and risk tolerance.5,6 None of the nine items is a market forecast.
One portfolio, four goals
All four start with $40,000 in a broad stock index fund and save $1,000 a month. Each asks whether to keep buying stocks.
| Investor | Goal | Other facts | Answer |
|---|---|---|---|
| Maya | The $40,000 is a down payment due in 2 years | Stable job | Move the down payment to T-bills or a 2-year Treasury |
| Sam | Retirement in 34 years | Salaried, 6 months of cash, full 401(k) match | Yes, keep buying stocks |
| Jordan | Retirement in 34 years | $12,000 card balance near 22%, commission pay, 1 month of cash | Pay off the card and build cash first |
| Alex | $1 million by 45 | Feels behind; asking about a few high-growth stocks or crypto | Save more or move the date |
The figures that follow come from Aswath Damodaran’s annual US returns for 1928 through 2025: the S&P 500, 3-month T-bills, the 10-year Treasury and CPI inflation.7 Each window starts at a year-end and adds the year’s saving at each later year-end, in today’s dollars, so the dollar amount rises with inflation. Fees and taxes are ignored. The data are US only; a broader sample of countries is less kind to stocks, as Sam’s case notes.
Maya: the money is due in two years
Maya’s $40,000 is the down payment on a condo she plans to buy in late 2028. The amount is fixed in dollars and the date is firm. For every two-year window since 1928, here is how often $40,000 set aside in each asset ended below $40,000:
| Held in | Ended below $40,000 | Worst two years |
|---|---|---|
| T-bills, rolled | 0 of 97 | +0.1% |
| 10-year Treasury, rolled | 9 of 97 | -21.5% |
| 60/40 stocks and Treasuries | 17 of 97 | -37.0% |
| S&P 500 | 16 of 97 | -57.9% |
The worst stock run, 1930–31, would have left her $16,821. More recent ones would still have cost her the condo: 2001–02 left $27,515 and 2007–08 left $26,771. The 97 windows overlap; there are only 49 separate two-year periods since 1928.
On November 18, 2026, a 2-year Treasury yielded 4.80% and a 3-month bill 4.34%.8 A Treasury maturing before her closing date or a CD of the same term pays the dollars on the date, and a Treasury money market fund holds its value with very little risk. Her answer is no for this $40,000. The $1,000 a month she saves for retirement can still go into stocks. If her purchase could slide by several years, the answer would move toward stocks; What Makes an Investment Safe? scores how much a few years of slack change it.
Sam: the money has 34 years
Sam is saving for retirement at 62. He is salaried, keeps six months of expenses in cash and gets his full 401(k) match. His goal is $1.2 million in today’s dollars, which at a 4% withdrawal rate pays about $48,000 a year on top of Social Security.
At a constant 5% a year after inflation, his $1,000 a month gets him to $1.25 million. At 3% it reaches $812,000. The return assumption moves the saving he needs by 64%:
| If returns average, after inflation | Saving needed per month |
|---|---|
| 0% | $2,843 |
| 3% | $1,553 |
| 5% | $948 |
So the asset choice matters. Run his actual plan, $40,000 now and $12,000 a year, through every 34-year window from 1928 to 1992, and the ends of the table swap places. T-bills go from never missing to always missing, and stocks from the deepest losses to the best record:
| Held in | Maya fell short | Sam fell short |
|---|---|---|
| T-bills, rolled | 0% | 100% |
| 10-year Treasury, rolled | 9% | 98% |
| 60/40 stocks and Treasuries | 18% | 32% |
| S&P 500 | 16% | 3% |
Stocks reached Sam’s goal in 63 of 65 start years, with a median ending balance of $2.14 million. T-bills never did; their median was $492,000. Two cautions apply. The 65 windows overlap so heavily that 1928–2025 holds fewer than three separate 34-year periods. And the US is one country: across 39 developed markets, Anarkulova, Cederburg and O’Doherty estimate a 12% chance that stocks lose to inflation over 30 years.9
Sam’s job gives a second reason. Bodie, Merton and Samuelson showed in a life-cycle model that a worker who can adjust how much and how long he works can rationally take more investment risk, because a bad market can be met by working more or retiring later.10 How far to take that is still argued. Vanguard’s 2065 target-date fund, the vintage for someone Sam’s age, held about 91% stocks in September 2026 (Target-Date Fund vs. DIY 401(k))11, and a lifecycle study by the same Anarkulova team favors 100% stocks, one-third US and two-thirds international, for a typical US couple who hold through crashes.12 Lifecycle Asset Allocation and 60/40, Target-Date, or 100% Stocks cover that range. Either way his answer is yes. His saving rate can substitute for some of the stock share: over the same 65 windows, a 60/40 mix with $1,500 a month reached the goal in 57 and ended with the same median as all stocks with $1,000, about $2.14 million.
Jordan: the same goal on a fragile balance sheet
Jordan’s goal and date match Sam’s. The difference is $12,000 on a credit card, pay that is mostly commission, and one month of expenses in cash. The Federal Reserve’s average rate at commercial banks on card accounts that paid interest was 22.36% in the third quarter of 2026, a preliminary figure.13 At that rate the balance costs $2,683 a year. Sending his $1,000 a month to the card clears it in 14 months, with $1,711 of interest along the way.
Every dollar of that balance he pays off earns 22.36%, with no risk and no tax. The S&P 500 compounded 10.0% a year from 1928 to 2025 before inflation. One thing beats paying the card: an employer match, which adds the employer’s money to each dollar contributed. Jordan should take that first.
Cash comes next. Commission income can fall in the same recession that sinks stock prices, and a one-month reserve turns a lost quarter of pay into a forced sale near the bottom. Emergency Fund Sizing suggests up to 12 months for 1099 or heavily variable income. Once the card is gone and the reserve is built, Jordan’s answer becomes Sam’s. Money Path lays out the full order.
Alex: the goal needs a return stocks rarely delivered
Alex wants $1 million in today’s dollars by 45, feels behind, and is asking about moving the $40,000 into a few high-growth stocks or crypto. The impulse is common. In Northwestern Mutual’s 2026 survey, 73% of people who hold or are considering speculative assets agreed they do it because they feel financially behind and believe these investments will help them reach their goals more effectively than traditional methods; among Gen Z the figure was 80%.14
Working backward from the goal shows the problem. With $40,000 and $1,000 a month for 17 years, Alex needs 13.0% a year after inflation. The S&P 500 compounded 6.8% after inflation from 1928 to 2025. It beat 13% in 6 of 82 rolling 17-year windows, all of them starting in 1942–43, 1948–49 or 1982–83. With Alex’s saving added each year, stocks reached $1 million in 7 of 82 start years, with a median ending balance of about $504,000. T-bills, Treasuries and the 60/40 mix never got there.
Picking a handful of stocks widens the range of outcomes without raising the typical one. From 1926 to 2016, the median US common stock had a lifetime buy-and-hold return below one-month T-bills, and a small minority of stocks accounted for the market’s entire gain over bills.15 Most Stocks Lose to T-Bills covers the research. A concentrated bet raises the odds of both a big win and a big loss, and the typical outcome leaves Alex with less than the index fund would have.
The goal itself is where the reliable fixes are. At 5% after inflation:
- Saving $2,864 a month instead of $1,000 reaches $1 million at 45.
- Saving $2,000 a month reaches it in about 21 years, at 49.
- Keeping $1,000 a month reaches it in about 30 years, at 58.
- Keeping the plan and the date ends near $409,000 at 45.
If the only test is whether a plan crosses $1 million on a date, a long shot can look rational on paper. Judge it by what the misses leave too.
Income outside the portfolio changes the answer too. In simulations of Health and Retirement Study couples saving in 401(k)s until retirement, Poterba, Rauh, Venti and Wise found that counting Social Security and pension income raised the value of an all-stock 401(k) relative to all bonds.16 The same logic lets a retiree whose pension and Social Security cover essential spending carry more stock than one who lives on withdrawals; Social Security, Pensions and Asset Allocation works through that case.
Most people have all four goals at once
Maya, Sam, Jordan and Alex are often one person: a down payment in a few years, retirement in decades, a card balance, and a number that feels out of reach. The answer to “should I buy more stocks?” is then per dollar. The down payment goes to T-bills, retirement dollars to stocks, and the card gets paid first.
Sorting money by goal need not cost anything in efficiency. Das, Markowitz, Scheid and Statman showed that a portfolio built goal by goal, each with its own required return and tolerance for missing it, adds up to a mean-variance-efficient whole when short selling is allowed, and loses very little when it is not.17 Still look at the combined portfolio once a year for overlap, total stock share and which accounts hold what.
If you don’t know your goals yet
At 22 or 28, plenty of people cannot say whether they will want a house, children, graduate school or an early exit from work. That is no reason to leave money idle. A reasonable default:
- A starter cash reserve of about one month of expenses.
- Every dollar of employer match.
- Pay off debt above about 10%.
- Retirement-account money in a low-cost target-date fund or a global index fund.
- Money you might need within about five years, for a move or a degree, in T-bills or high-yield savings until it has a date.
US retirement rules already accept an age-based default without personal goals. The Labor Department’s safe harbor for 401(k) default investments covers target-date funds whose allocations “are not required to take into account risk tolerances, investments or other preferences of an individual participant.”18 At year-end 2024, 59% of Vanguard’s plan participants held a single target-date fund.19 Revisit the plan when a goal gets a date and a price.
What to include when you ask for advice
Whether you are posting on a forum, asking a friend or meeting an adviser, these seven lines let someone give you an answer that fits:
Goal: what this money is for, how much (in today's dollars), and when Flexibility: can the date slide or the amount shrink, and by how much? Funding: already saved toward it, and saved each month Income: salaried or variable, and months of expenses held in cash Debts: each balance and its interest rate Accounts: every account as a share of the whole portfolio, plus tax bracket Question: the one decision you want help with
The Bogleheads template asks for most of this and adds fund menus and expense ratios. It assumes the goal is retirement, so add the first two lines when it is not. Professional planners work in the same order: the CFP Board’s practice standards put understanding your circumstances and identifying goals before analyzing any course of action.20
Try it with your own goal
The calculator works backward from one goal: what it needs each month, the return your current saving needs, and how the same plan did in each asset since 1928. The buttons load Maya, Sam and Alex.
What the evidence supports
Financial economics has treated a portfolio as a way to pay for spending across a lifetime since Samuelson and Merton’s 1969 papers on lifetime portfolio selection.21,22 The case studies above apply that idea to one goal at a time. The evidence that stating goals changes what people do is thinner:
- Planning and wealth move together, causation unproven. Ameriks, Caplin and Leahy found that a one-standard-deviation increase in self-reported planning effort went with about 20% higher net worth among 500 TIAA-CREF households, and about 15% when they instrumented for planning. The authors argue their instruments largely rule out wealth driving planning, but say their results do not show that raising someone’s planning would raise their wealth much.23 How to Write a Household Financial Plan covers the study’s limits in detail.
- Goals went with more risk-taking. In UK survey data covering 2006 to 2016, households with no savings goals had a risky-asset share of 6%, and those with four or more goals 16%. The study shows association only.24
- Automatic rules work better than good intentions. When one firm began enrolling new hires in its 401(k) automatically, 86% of new hires joined, against 37% of those hired the year before, and 76% of the new participants kept the 3% default contribution rate.25 At another firm, workers who pre-committed future raises to saving went from 3.5% to 13.6% of pay over 40 months; the 162 who joined chose to, so the result is not a randomized estimate.26
- Classes fade. A meta-analysis of 201 studies found financial education explained about 0.1% of the variation in later financial behavior, with effects near zero 20 months out.27 That is why a goal should become an automatic contribution, and why the calculator above asks about one decision you face now.
Where this advice goes too far
- Some advice needs no goal. Diversify, keep costs low, do not borrow to invest more than you could hold through a crash, and keep employer stock small. Those hold for nearly everyone.
- A default beats a stalled plan. Waiting to invest until every goal is priced costs years of compounding.
- Caution goal by goal can backfire. Holding every goal’s money in cash for near certainty leaves long-term money earning little. For Sam’s goal, T-bills fell short in every one of the 65 windows.
- Odds of hitting a number are one test. How far short a plan falls when it misses matters too.
- The right stock share is still contested. Goals tell you which dollars can take stock risk. Researchers still disagree on how much of the long-term money should be in stocks.
Key takeaways
- “Should I buy more stocks?” depends on the goal. What the money is for, when it is due, and what else is on your balance sheet decide it. Broker rules list at least nine facts about you, from time horizon to liquidity needs, behind any recommendation.
- Near dates call for cash or Treasuries. For a fixed $40,000 bill due in two years, US stocks ended short in 16 of 97 start years since 1928, at worst by 58%. T-bills never did.
- Decades favor stocks. For Sam’s modeled $1.2 million goal in 34 years, stocks got there in 63 of 65 start years and T-bills in none, in overlapping windows from one country’s history.
- Pay 22% debt before buying stocks, after taking any employer match, and hold cash sized to how steady your income is.
- A goal that needs 13% a year after inflation needs a new plan. US stocks beat that in 6 of 82 17-year windows. Saving, timing and goal size are the levers that work.
- No goal yet? Take the match, clear high-rate debt, use a target-date or global index fund for retirement money, and park maybe-soon money in T-bills.
How Summitward helps
Write the goals down once
The Financial Plan page keeps your ranked goals, their dates and amounts, and the rules that follow from them, with a version history.
Open the Financial PlanFrequently asked questions
Should I buy more stocks right now?
Yes for money you will not need for many years, once high-rate debt is paid and you hold a cash reserve. No for money due within a few years. Over two-year windows since 1928, the S&P 500 lost money in 16 of 97, and the date you need the money does not move when the market does.
Is 100% stocks too risky at 25?
For retirement money with a stable income and a cash reserve, lifecycle models often put a 25-year-old at or near 100% stocks (Lifecycle Asset Allocation), and Vanguard’s 2065 target-date fund holds about 91%. It is too risky for money with a near date, and riskier for someone whose income moves with the stock market, such as a tech worker paid in company stock (Human Capital Risk for Tech Workers).
Where should I keep a down payment?
In T-bills, a Treasury money market fund, a CD, or a Treasury that matures before your closing date. A 2-year Treasury yielded 4.80% on November 18, 2026. Stocks fell short of a two-year, fixed-dollar goal in 16 of 97 start years since 1928.
Should I pay off debt or invest?
Take any employer match first, then pay off debt above about 10%. Paying a 22% card is a guaranteed 22% return with no risk; stocks compounded 10.0% a year from 1928 to 2025. Debt between Treasury yields and about 10% is a closer call, and debt below Treasury yields is usually not worth paying early.
What if I don’t know my financial goals?
Use a default until you do: a small cash reserve, the full employer match, no high-rate debt, and retirement money in a low-cost target-date or global index fund. Keep money you might need within about five years in T-bills. Revisit when a goal gets a date and a price.
How do I ask for portfolio advice online?
State the goal, its amount and date, how flexible it is, what you have saved and save each month, how steady your income is, your debts with rates, and every account as a share of the whole. The Bogleheads “Asking Portfolio Questions” template covers most of it.
Related guides
- What Makes an Investment Safe? the same assets scored against bills of every date and kind.
- Lifecycle Asset Allocation why human capital lets young savers hold more stock.
- Money Path the order for match, debt, cash and investing.
- How to Write a Household Financial Plan turn ranked goals into rules on one page.
- Just Keep Buying which buckets the habit fits and which it does not.
- What Real Return Should You Assume for Stocks? the return assumption behind every funding plan.
- Most Stocks Lose to T-Bills why a few picks are a worse bet than the index.
- Social Security, Pensions and Asset Allocation the same question for retirees with guaranteed income.
Sources
Case-study figures are our calculations from Damodaran’s data (source 7) and assume constant returns where stated. They describe modeled households, not forecasts.
- FINRA Investor Education Foundation (2025). Investors in the United States, 4th edition. Online survey of 2,861 US adults with investments outside retirement accounts, fielded July to December 2024.
- Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System (2026). Economic Well-Being of U.S. Households in 2025: Savings and Investments. Probability-based panel, 12,934 respondents, October 2025.
- Charles Schwab (2025). Modern Wealth Survey 2025. Online survey of 2,000 Americans aged 21 to 75, April to May 2025.
- Bogleheads forum. Asking Portfolio Questions. Posted September 22, 2007; revised through 2021.
- 17 CFR 240.15l-1(b)(2), Regulation Best Interest, definition of retail customer investment profile.
- FINRA Rule 2111, Suitability.
- Damodaran, A. Historical Returns on Stocks, Bonds and Bills: 1928-Current. NYU Stern, updated January 2026. Annual S&P 500, 3-month T-bill and 10-year Treasury returns and CPI-U inflation.
- U.S. Department of the Treasury. Daily Treasury Par Yield Curve Rates, November 18, 2026.
- Anarkulova, A., Cederburg, S., & O’Doherty, M. S. (2022). Stocks for the Long Run? Evidence from a Broad Sample of Developed Markets. Journal of Financial Economics, 143(1), 409-433.
- Bodie, Z., Merton, R. C., & Samuelson, W. F. (1992). Labor Supply Flexibility and Portfolio Choice in a Life Cycle Model. Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control, 16(3-4), 427-449.
- Vanguard. Vanguard Target Retirement 2065 Fund fact sheet, September 30, 2026. Underlying funds: 54.9% US stock index, 36.6% international stock index, 8.5% bond index funds.
- Anarkulova, A., Cederburg, S., & O’Doherty, M. S. Beyond the Status Quo: A Critical Assessment of Lifecycle Investment Advice. Working paper.
- Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System. G.19 Consumer Credit, released November 6, 2026. Commercial bank interest rate on credit card plans, accounts assessed interest, Q3 2026 (preliminary).
- Northwestern Mutual (2026). 2026 Planning & Progress Study, Wave I data deck. Online survey by The Harris Poll of 4,375 US adults, January 2026.
- Bessembinder, H. (2018). Do Stocks Outperform Treasury Bills?. Journal of Financial Economics, 129(3), 440-457.
- Poterba, J., Rauh, J., Venti, S., & Wise, D. (2003). Utility Evaluation of Risk in Retirement Saving Accounts. NBER Working Paper 9892.
- Das, S., Markowitz, H., Scheid, J., & Statman, M. (2010). Portfolio Optimization with Mental Accounts. Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis, 45(2), 311-334.
- 29 CFR 2550.404c-5(e)(4)(i), Fiduciary relief for investments in qualified default investment alternatives.
- Vanguard (2025). How America Saves 2025. Recordkeeping data on Vanguard plan participants, year-end 2024.
- CFP Board. Code of Ethics and Standards of Conduct, Practice Standards for the Financial Planning Process.
- Samuelson, P. A. (1969). Lifetime Portfolio Selection by Dynamic Stochastic Programming. Review of Economics and Statistics, 51(3), 239-246.
- Merton, R. C. (1969). Lifetime Portfolio Selection under Uncertainty: The Continuous-Time Case. Review of Economics and Statistics, 51(3), 247-257.
- Ameriks, J., Caplin, A., & Leahy, J. (2003). Wealth Accumulation and the Propensity to Plan. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 118(3), 1007-1047.
- Changwony, F. K., Campbell, K., & Tabner, I. T. (2021). Savings Goals and Wealth Allocation in Household Financial Portfolios. Journal of Banking & Finance, 124, 106028.
- Madrian, B. C., & Shea, D. F. (2001). The Power of Suggestion: Inertia in 401(k) Participation and Savings Behavior. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 116(4), 1149-1187.
- Thaler, R. H., & Benartzi, S. (2004). Save More Tomorrow: Using Behavioral Economics to Increase Employee Saving. Journal of Political Economy, 112(S1), S164-S187.
- Fernandes, D., Lynch, J. G., & Netemeyer, R. G. (2014). Financial Literacy, Financial Education, and Downstream Financial Behaviors. Management Science, 60(8), 1861-1883.
More in Getting Started
Browse all getting started guidesGet new guides by email
Evidence-based, no jargon. At most two emails a month. Unsubscribe any time.
Try it in Summitward
See your household financial plan in action with your own financial data. Free to start, no credit card required.